Stalin Man Or Monster Essay

But even this truism is now coming under attack by Revisionists.

Prominent among those questioning the role played by Hitler is Ernst Topitsch, whose book, Stalin's War, has just appeared in English translation in the United States, published by the respected St. Topitsch is a graduate of the University of Vienna, a member of the Paris Institute of Philosophy, and a professor at Graz University in Austria.

From Herod to Pol Pot, Genghis Khan to Hitler, Ivan the Terrible to Saddam Hussein, we have been drawn to the edge of the abyss for a glance into the bottomless and cold darkness of Great Evil. Even in this gallery of mega-rogues, Joseph Stalin stands apart.

Although second to his imitator Mao Zedong in the absolute numbers of the compatriots killed (shot, tortured to death in prisons, starved in villages, murdered in concentration camps) and to Pol Pot in the proportion of the country's population exterminated, Stalin may be unmatched, at least in modern times, in the number of people his policies affected -- in his impact on the contemporary world.

A new situation now presented itself to Stalin if the German Army were defeated, the Soviets could be masters of Europe.

Stalin Man Or Monster Essay Powers Of Horror An Essay On Abjection

As the author points out, given the inaccessibility of Kremlin archives, "it cannot be stated exactly when the decision was made to embark on this strategy." Topitsch is convinced that Stalin set out to provoke Hitler to attack the Soviet Union, just as Franklin Roosevelt maneuvered Japan into "firing the first shot."Topitsch contends that regardless of what Hitler did, Stalin was preparing to attack Germany, most likely in 1942.

Resentful of his deformity (his left arm was permanently damaged in an accident), he was vengeful, never forgetting (let alone forgiving) a slight.

According to his boyhood friends, Iosif "coddled grievances for years," and, in Service's words, saw "malevolent human agency in every personal or political problem he encountered." He joined the fledgling party at the age of 20, having left the Tiflis (Tbilisi) Theological Seminary a few months before graduation in 1899.

Simply stated, his well-argued thesis is that Stalin, not Hitler, was the central figure of the war.

The author summarizes the evolution of his thinking on these matters at the outset of his study: In line with prevailing opinion, for many years I considered Hitler to be the main character in the drama of the Second World War, and held his policy of violent expansion and aggression to be the most important cause of its outbreak.


Comments Stalin Man Or Monster Essay

  • Free term paper on Stalin Man or Monster? - Planet Papers

    Source A shows Stalin to be a monster responsible for the death of millions of people. Stalin´s policies. Sign In Now to Read Entire Essay.…

  • Joseph Stalin A Good Leader Essays -- Soviet Union, Joseph.

    Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin, World War II - Joseph Stalin A Good Leader. Djugashvili, which he later took the name Stalin, meaning “man of steel. Snow", Stalin is portrayed as the monster really was and should be remembered as.…

  • Stalin - hero or villain? The Perspective

    With a name meaning “Man of Steel,” Stalin has been decried as Hitler-esque, but has also been hailed as the savior who freed Europe from Hitler's murderous.…

  • Essay on Stalin's Propaganda -- Stalin, Propaganda, Russia,

    Stalin, Propaganda, Russia, - Stalin's Propaganda. a tool to brainwash the Russian people to think he was a man of character, integrity and power. Snow", Stalin is portrayed as the monster really was and should be remembered as.…

  • Stalin, Man of the Borderlands - jstor

    In tracing the individual contours of Stalin's identity formation, this essay utilizes. thus establishing the cosmos and he also overcomes monsters that would.…

  • Joseph Stalin Essay Bartleby

    Free Essays from Bartleby Joseph Stalin Joseph Stalin was one of the biggest. “The man who turned the Soviet Union from a backward country into a world. Almost everyone knows what a monster Adolf Hitler was, but most people do not.…

  • Stalin Man or Monster - GCSE History - Marked by Teachers.

    Stalin was a man who ruled in the name of the people, yet stopped at no crime for. The views about Stalin differ, some people see him as a man and some as a monster. Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays.…

  • IWonder - Joseph Stalin National hero or cold-blooded. - BBC

    Stalin's name meant "man of steel". He was the supreme ruler of the Soviet Union and one of the most powerful and murderous dictators in history.…

  • Stalin - Arlindo Correia

    As these new books make clear, Stalin wasn't just a monster; he was a. of the men who engineered them beginning with first-rate essays on Stalin and the.…

  • Stalin – the watchful monster. Blog

    I've just finished a long essay – more than 5,000 words – on Joseph Stalin for the Key Leaders section of the site. And writing it. Unlike Hitler or Mussolini, Stalin was not bombastic. Stalin. He was a very unprincipled man…

The Latest from ©