Trump was not issuing a frightening call to crush dissent.
He was engaged in the mannered anti-elitism that’s part and parcel of democracy as we know it.
Trump’s last remaining opponent, Ohio governor John Kasich, had withdrawn from the race three days earlier.
When Trump made the remark quoted by Müller, he was the Republican nominee in everything but name, yet most Republican leaders still hadn’t endorsed him.
One can see how this anti-elitism might take a Robespierrean turn against pluralism, but this is a danger in democracies, as Müller fully acknowledges.
Toward the end of his book, he points out that “populism is strong in places with weak party systems,” and he suggests that populism is an outgrowth of the decline of strong parties across the West.His supporters are thrilled that in Trump, they’ve found someone who expresses their concerns about the future of America.As we’ll see, these concerns fit the usual pattern of politics in modern nation-states, in which .” Political scientists use “sociotropic” to mean “concern for the common good.” In a sociotropic-nationalist polity, this concern usually takes the form of wanting to solve the social and economic problems facing one’s conationals.Almost everyone, including President Trump and the vast majority of his supporters, would agree that he is a populist.Usually, this is thought to entail that he, and they, are opponents of the status quo (which he portrays as “rigged” by “elites”). And it’s all too tempting for his critics to go along with the act—not only objecting to his odious policies and questionable sanity, but denying any continuities between him and “us.” Everyone is happy if Trump is treated as the “other.” But in many crucial respects, he isn’t.What Trump and his supporters The fact that populists may support cultural pluralism against political correctness poses a clear problem for Müller’s claim that populism is inherently anti-pluralistic. First, he warns that it’s counterproductive to argue against populism on liberal grounds: “we should stop the thoughtless invocation of ‘liberal democracy’” against populists, because the populists will notice the hypocrisy involved. “While they may have won an initial election fair and square,” he writes, populists “quickly start tampering with the institutional machinery of democracy in the name of so-called real people.” It doesn’t take much imagination to envision Trump trying to engage in institutional deck-stacking or even dictatorship, as has been successfully attempted in Europe and South America. Yet one must again wonder if this isn’t a problem with democracy itself, especially under modern conditions.Threats to the rule of law troubled liberal critics of George W.Trump’s favorite president, Andrew Jackson, picked this lock in 1828 by founding a new party—the Democratic party—to escape the grip of the old ones.Theodore Roosevelt tried the same thing with his Progressive party in 1912.In other words, populists oppose political pluralism as such.This may be true of European and South American populists, as it was true of fascists, but I don’t think a careful listen shows it to be true of Trump, let alone his supporters.
Comments Populism Vs Elitism Essay
Populists and the Perversion of Academic Expertise - The.
Mar 9, 2018. "Isn't that elitist?" a student asks her classmate, who has suggested that we cannot formulate an opinion about artificial intelligence without first.…
Five views Is populism really a threat to democracy? EUROPP
As a first step in assessing whether populism is a threat to democracy or.…
Populism vs. Constitutionalism? - Foundation for Law, Justice.
Populism has two direct opposites elitism and pluralism. contrast to populism and elitism, pluralism is based. summary, the 'standard account' postulates that.…
Eleanor Catton on Literature and Elitism
Dec 9, 2013. A non-elitist writer, a populist writer, would have used a more recognisable. That an essay published online, with no restrictions of access or.…
Opinion How the Left Embraced Elitism - The New York Times
Feb 11, 2019. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Ed Markey. For example, in the lead essay of the conservative journal National. The great paradox of progressive populism is that it leads to elitism in its purist form.…
Trump as Populist - Niskanen Center
Sep 20, 2017. Populists have “reasons for anger and frustration,” Müller writes, and “most of them. because of the anti-elitism built into democratic politics. Theodore Roosevelt, Social Justice and Popular Rule Essays, Addresses, and.…
The Myth of “Populism” - Jacobin
Jan 3, 2018. “Populism is a toxic brew,” notes Harvard historian Niall Ferguson in a recent essay, “as well as. What — and, most importantly, who — did this original Populist. Empirically dubious and politically elitist, few academics still.…
Jeff Bell on Populism & the Rise of Donald Trump National.
Feb 24, 2018. His two books, Populism and Elitism 1992 and The Case for Polarized Politics. To me,” Jeff wrote in a 2008 essay for the Weekly Standard.…
Populism, is it Democracy's Bastard or Twin? The Case of the.
Jun 27, 2017. Is populism a threat for democracy or a contribution to improve a system whose. The essay argues that, on one hand, there is no democracy without. of populism according to the construction of people, the anti-elitism, and.…