Its relevance to math, however, is particularly intriguing – and somewhat unsettling in light of the fact that most of us still think in behaviorist terms.

Mathematics is the subject in which practice homework seems to be most commonly prescribed, so this is as good a place as any to understand the limits of the whole idea.[4] An emphasis on practice to reinforce skills proceeds naturally from the assumption that kids primarily need to learn “math facts”: the ability to say “42” as soon as they hear the stimulus “6 x 7,” and a familiarity with step-by-step procedures (sometimes called algorithms) for all kinds of problems — carrying numbers while subtracting, subtracting while dividing, reducing fractions to the lowest common denominator, and so forth.

The more they’re given algorithms and told exactly what to do, the farther behind they fall in terms of grasping these concepts.

“Mindless mimicry mathematics,” as the National Research Council calls it, is the norm in our schools, from single-digit addition in first grade to trigonometry in high school.

The behavior might consist of a rodent finding its way through a maze or a child borrowing from the tens’ place.

For a behaviorist, these actions are different only in degree, and the same theory applies equally well to both.

Thus, to justify sending students home with a worksheet full of practice problems on the grounds that it reinforces skills is to say that what matters is not understanding but behavior.

In the 1920s and ‘30s, when Watson was formulating his theory that would come to dominate the way we teach students (not to mention the way we raise children and manage employees), a much less famous researcher named William Brownell was challenging the drill-and-practice approach to mathematics that had already taken root.

“If one is to be successful in quantitative thinking, one needs a fund of meanings, not a myriad of ‘automatic responses,’” he wrote. Repetition does not lead to understandings.” In fact, if “arithmetic becomes meaningful, it becomes so drill.”[1] An emphasis on making meaning is directly opposed to the view that learning consists of the acquisition of a collection of behaviors.

Brownell’s insights about math instruction have been expanded and enriched by a long line of experts who have come to realize that the behaviorist model is, if you’ll excuse the expression, deeply superficial.

## Comments Daily Homework Is Necessary For Students Essay

## The Benefits of Homework Essay -- education techniques

One benefit of homework is that it helps the student develop essential skills. Homework is necessary for more than just a grade; it is an assignment that. on a daily basis, and some only assign homework when it seems to be necessary.…

## Pros and Cons of Homework –

Or is the added stress that homework places on students and parents doing. To get better at a skill, repetition is often necessary. The time allotted for each area of study in school, especially in K-12, is often limited to 1 hour or less per day.…

## Should students really have homework? – College-Homework.

Answering the question of whether students should have homework, whether it is necessary, and how homework affects the studying process. Students.…

## Is Homework Necessary? Too Much Homework Is Bad for.

Mar 30, 2012. Piling on the homework doesn't help kids do better in school. However, homework only bolsters students' academic performance during their.…

## Do Students Really Need Practice Homework? - Alfie Kohn

Giving students homework that involves drill and practice is often said to. them, and repetition seems to be necessary to memorize rules kids don't understand. Using just ten minutes a day, students end up reading over 100 college-level. Essays in favor of homework generally reflect a tendency to regard children as.…

## Homework is it worth the hassle? Teacher Network The.

Feb 7, 2017. Parents and educators question the value of setting assignments for students. But what does the neuroscience say? Helen Silvester.…

## When Is Homework Necessary? - Waldorf Library

Homework is as controversial as it is unwanted, but is it really necessary? This is a. my students to practice writing essays, I suggested creating a collection of. Every day during a main lesson I would call students up to the front, where the.…

## Is Homework Good or Bad for Kids? - ThoughtCo

There are 10 reasons that prove homework is good for kids, and 5 reasons why it. Homework isn't fun for students to do or for teachers to grade, so why do it?…

## Reasons Why Homework Is Bad For Your Child HuffPost Life

Oct 7, 2016. If they are unable to go school each day to acquire the skills they require. Let's now dive deep and look at why homework is bad for students.…

## Is homework a necessary evil?

For as long as kids have been whining about doing their homework, parents. In a recent study of Spanish students, Rubén Fernández-Alonso, PhD, and. of homework per day, scores declined Journal of Educational Psychology, 2015.…